The Bodhisattva Beat
Music and Life

Porcupine Tree & Bigelf: Live, May 2nd 2010

Live 2010

Last Sunday I had the opportunity to see Porcupine Tree in Detroit. The beauty of this was twofold. First, bands like this don’t come to my area very often. Second, I was able to get a Sunday night off during U of M graduation weekend (very busy, especially when the President gives the commencement address).

The opening act Was Bigelf. I was unfamiliar with them, so I didn’t know what to expect. What a treat they were. It’s keyboard laden retro heavy rock all the way, with a bit of stage theatrics. The best description is a cross between Deep Purple and Alice Cooper.

Impresario (or Damon Fox) is the lead singer, keyboard player, and front man. He has long dark hair, a beard, wears eyeliner, and dons a top hat. All the guys sported some kind of goth influence in their fashion choices. Impresario has his equipment (including a Mellotron) positioned at each side, so he can play two boards while facing the audience. It gives a lot a room for stage antics, while still jamming on the keys.

The music itself was just about what you would expect. Solid retro, Ian Gillan style vocals, blistering guitar, and no surprises. It’s a lot of fun at a show, and these guys pull it off very well. My friend who was with me thought that the compositions might not hold up as well on a studio recording, and it made me wonder as well (I have since found he was correct). But it didn’t matter, because we were having a great time, and the band is a great live act. Not everybody shared this opinion (especially the guy behind me, who was bitching about them to no end), but I would definitely go see Bigelf again.

During the break between acts, there was announcement about Porcupine Tree’s live performance of “The Incident.” I guess I hadn’t researched this tour fully enough, but it was a bit of a disappointment for my buddy and I. It’s a completely reasonable choice, but neither of us are huge fans of the last three albums. Be that as it may, we still expected a good concert.

Porcupine Tree did not let us down. It is an ambitious thing to perform an album long opus, and the band did it masterfully. Of course the multimedia projections added quite a bit to the experience. The second half provided an eclectic mix of Porcupine Tree songs. “Anesthetize” was absolutely stunning, and “Blackest Eyes” drove the crowd into a frenzy. They did go back to “Lightbulb Sun” for the first two numbers, but nothing else before “In Absentia.” “Hatesong” and “Russia on Ice” are good, but I would rather have heard something like the title track from that album, or “How is your Life Today?”

They didn’t really stray from the studio recordings, but their compositions generally don’t leave much room for improvisation. The difference is the energy, and watching the musicians perform. Gavin Harrison is especially great to see as he throws together his combinations. This I already knew, as I had seen him with King Crimson in 2008.

My only issue was the set list. For many of us this was our first opportunity to see Porcupine Tree. It would have been nice for them to throw out a few more things for fans of the earlier albums. But, you can’t have everything. The bottom line is that it was a really good show.  I would definitely recommend catching a show if you can.

Bookmark and Share


7 Responses to “Porcupine Tree & Bigelf: Live, May 2nd 2010”

  1. I honestly wouldn’t have expected you to attend this show H.T. I had considered going, and then forgot about it until after the fact. Glad to hear that it was a mostly positive experience.


  2. We saw both bands last year, Bigelf as part of the ProgNation tour, PT at the Ram’s Head in Baltimore (with King’s X as a support act). Personally speaking, neither band impressed me, probably in both cases because of problems with the stage/venue. The Baltimore venue in particular was extremely uncomfortable, though the material from “The Incident” was not particularly impressive either. Perhaps next time we’ll get to see them in a better situation.

  3. Hi! My name is Juan. Im the keyboard player (and illustrator) in “William Gray”, a band from Argentina. Navigating the web I found your review of our first album, and I wanted to say hi, and thank you for that! We are recording the second one, I guess it will be ready by the end of the year.
    Also: I guess you`re a zen bodhisattva! hehe, I used to practice for many years, with my roshi! Now Im a “Falun gong” practitioner. Keep that zazen going!
    Thanks again!

    • Hi Juan,
      Great to hear from you. I was just listening to “Living Fossils” the other day, and was wondering if you were going to do another one. Keep me posted.

      And yes, I practice Korean Zen.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: